My latest car is an estate/touring with a set of roof rails so requires a roofbar that can clamp directly to the rail. After looking at the OEM version I decided to take a closer look at the Thule Wing bars. Mainly because the OEM version sat quite high off the roof and from BMW would have cost a small ransom. I have had a few different sets of Thule bars in the past and still own/use a set of Thule ProRide 591 bike carriers so it made sense to have a look at the newer offerings. In addition Thule have a pretty good reputation world wide and certainly have great customer service here in the UK.
The Thule WingBar Edge is the most safe and silent roof rack, and now available in a low fit. It is a universal fit (use selector tool above to see if available for your vehicle) by using telescopic feet. It's low profile and close fit to the roof creates a stunning look and is available in the following models 9581-9586, 9591-9596 in Black and Silver.
There were a few types of bar I could have chosen. Firstly the bog standard square bars, which are pretty good but they don’t have the T channel for quick attachment of bike carriers and roof boxes. They still work really well but I have a few bits that use the T bolt system and I really like it for ease and security. The second is the Aero bars system which I have used a great deal in the past. They are again good, but I found them to be a little noisy on the cars I have had in the past. This may have been down to the bars or the foot system, or the way I had fitted them. The Aero bars do have the T channel which still makes them a contender. OEM bars tend to be very similar to the Thule Aero bars anyway. However for a little bit more cash the Thule Wing bars offer a lower profile, a reported 55% reduction in drag compared to the Aero bars and a possibility of an overall quieter system. After a hunt around (see below) I got the Wing bars for the price of a set of Aero bars
N001 N002 N003 N004 N005 N006 N007 N008 N009 N010 N011 N012 N013 N014 N015 N016 N017 N018 N019 N020 N021 N022 N023 N024 N025 N026 N027 N028 N029 N030 N031 N032 N033 N034 N035 N036 N037 N038 N039 N040 N041 N042 N043 N044 N045 N046 N047 N048 N049 N050 N051 N052 N053 N054 N055 N056 N057 N058 N059 N060 N061 N062 N063 N064 N065 N066 N067 N068 N069 N070 N071 N072 N073 N074 N075 N076 N077 N078 N079 N080 N081 N082 N083 N084 N085 N086 N087 N088 N089 N090 N091 N092 N093 N094 N095 N096 N097 N098 N099 N100 N101 N102 N103 N104 N105 N106 N107 N108 N109 N110 N111 N112 N113 N114 N115 N116 N117 N118 N119 N120 N121 N122 N123 N124 N125 N126 N127 N128 N129 N130 N131 N132 N133 N134 N135 N136 N137 N138 N139 N140 N141 N142 N143 N144 N145 N146 N147 N148 N149 N150 N151 N152 N153 N154 N155 N156 N157 N158 N159 N160 N161 N162 N163 N164 N165 N166 N167 N168 N169 N170 N171 N172 N173 N174 N175 N176 N177 N178 N179 N180 N181 N182 N183 N184 N185 N186 N187 N188 N189 N190 N191 N192 N193 N194 N195 N196 N197 N198 N199 N200 N201 N202 N203 N204 N205 N206 N207 N208 N209 N210 N211 N212 N213 N214 N215 N216 N217 N218 N219 N220 N221 N222 N223 N224 N225 N226 N227 N228 N229 N230 N231 N232 N233 N234 N235 N236 N237 N238 N239 N240 N241 N242 N243 N244 N245 N246 N247 N248 N249 N250 N001R N002R N003R N004R N005R N006R N007R N008R N009R N010R N011R N012R N013R N014R N015R N016R N017R N018R N019R N020R N021R N022R N023R N024R N025R N026R N027R N028R N029R N030R N031R N032R N033R N034R N035R N036R N037R N038R N039R N040R N041R N042R N043R N044R N045R N046R N047R N048R N049R N050R N051R N052R N053R N054R N055R N056R N057R N058R N059R N060R N061R N062R N063R N064R N065R N066R N067R N068R N069R N070R N071R N072R N073R N074R N075R N076R N077R N078R N079R N080R N081R N082R N083R N084R N085R N086R N087R N088R N089R N090R N091R N092R N093R N094R N095R N096R N097R N098R N099R N100R N101R N102R N103R N104R N105R N106R N107R N108R N109R N110R N111R N112R N113R N114R N115R N116R N117R N118R N119R N120R N121R N122R N123R N124R N125R N126R N127R N128R N129R N130R N131R N132R N133R N134R N135R N136R N137R N138R N139R N140R N141R N142R N143R N144R N145R N146R N147R N148R N149R N150R N151R N152R N153R N154R N155R N156R N157R N158R N159R N160R N161R N162R N163R N164R N165R N166R N167R N168R N169R N170R N171R N172R N173R N174R N175R N176R N177R N178R N179R N180R N181R N182R N183R N184R N185R N186R N187R N188R N189R N190R N191R N192R N193R N194R N195R N196R N197R N198R N199R N200R N001M N002M N003M N004M N005M N006M N007M N008M N009M N010M N011M N012M N013M N014M N015M N016M N017M N018M N019M N020M N021M N022M N023M N024M N025M N026M N027M N028M N029M N030M N031M N032M N033M N034M N035M N036M N037M N038M N039M N040M N041M N042M N043M N044M N045M N046M N047M N048M N049M N050M N051M N052M N053M N054M N055M N056M N057M N058M N059M N060M N061M N062M N063M N064M N065M N066M N067M N068M N069M N070M N071M N072M N073M N074M N075M N076M N077M N078M N079M N080M N081M N082M N083M N084M N085M N086M N087M N088M N089M N090M N091M N092M N093M N094M N095M N096M N097M N098M N099M N100M N101M N102M N103M N104M N105M N106M N107M N108M N109M N110M N111M N112M N113M N114M N115M N116M N117M N118M N119M N120M N121M N122M N123M N124M N125M N126M N127M N128M N129M N130M N131M N132M N133M N134M N135M N136M N137M N138M N139M N140M N141M N142M N143M N144M N145M N146M N147M N148M N149M N150M N151M N152M N153M N154M N155M N156M N157M N158M N159M N160M N161M N162M N163M N164M N165M N166M N167M N168M N169M N170M N171M N172M N173M N174M N175M N176M N177M N178M N179M N180M N181M N182M N183M N184M N185M N186M N187M N188M N189M N190M N191M N192M N193M N194M N195M N196M N197M N198M N199M N200M
Thule v. Yakima - few topics bring about more angry debate. I've had my Thule system for about 5 years. I've hauled mountain bikes, skis, and three kayaks on my roof. It has worked flawlessly, albeit noisily. Yes, Yakima fans, the support bars will probably bend if you put three kayaks on them regularly. But if you are hauling that much weight with any frequency, you need a trailer, not a roof top rack system. Normal mortals won't have problems with bicycles, surf/whitewater kayaks, or one touring boat with an occasional second.
No, really, these things are seriously quiet while driving. They aren't inaudible but probably the closest you're gonna get without flat out removing them. I can't imagine any other cross bars being this quiet. And they give you rubber stripping to cover any holes (well, troughs actually) that might otherwise upset the laminar flow and cause unnecessary noise. Very nicely done.
But before you get a cargo box In almost all instances you’re going to need a roof rack system. These systems typically consist of two cross bars that bridge the width of your roof and can hold your box as well as other sport-specific carriers for bikes, skis, stand-up paddle boards, kayaks, and canoes — even a luxe rooftop camping tent. Depending on your vehicle, you may also need towers to attach the bars to your car and elevate them off your roof; get the same brand for both the cross bars and towers to assure compatibility. The variations on bar kits are staggering, but most major manufacturers have tools that help you narrow your options based on your car’s make, model, and year. The only time you don’t need bars? When you opt for a less-expensive cargo bag, which can sometimes be secured to factory mounts or rails found on some SUVs, trucks, and sedans.
Dear Phil, I have read over the reviews you sent us regarding the Thule Hull-a-Port. Being the manager in charge of returns, warranties, and exchanges at the Rack Warehouse I have had some experience with the problems noted in the reviews. The problem of the plastic mounting hardware breaking has happened before, but it is not at all common. Since we have sold the Hull-a-Port, we have had two sent back to us for warranty of this problem. Both of these racks came back last year (the first year this product was available), and this year's Hull-a-Ports have not been any problem for us. We have sold hundreds of units this summer, without one call about this problem. Usually people get back to us right away if there are problems with the system we sent them. I suggest the Hull-a-Port as an option for many people because of its ease of use and flexibility. If you are worried about the mounting brackets, I would suggest following one of the reviewer's advice and secure the boat down to the bar as well. I always use the load bar to secure my straps because the bars are always stronger than the accessory on top of them. Also, both the box the rack comes in and the instructions tell you that the bow and stern strap is required. To be on the safe side and ease your mind, use the bow / stern straps. Please call me if you have more questions or concerns. Thank you, Mary S., The Rack Warehouse 800-272-5362
© 2019 ProductReview.com.au Pty. Ltd. All Rights Reserved. General disclaimer: All third party trademarks, images and copyrights on this page are used for the purpose of comparative advertising, criticism or review. This is a public forum presenting user opinions on selected products and businesses, and as such the views expressed do not reflect the opinion of ProductReview.com.au. Further details in the disclaimer.
These bars are very aesthetically pleasing, having a lower profile and sleek ends which integrate into your car's design well. You do need to buy a specific fitting kit for your vehicle as can be expected. Installation itself took a matter of minutes, however the pictorial instructions do require a bit of patience and imagination to interpret on occasion. They're easy enough to install as one person, but this may be more difficult if you have a van or 4x4. Don't do what I began to do and assume that the thinner edge of the bar faces forward, it's actually the other way around. These bars are very quiet on their own, understandably louder with accessories/roof boxes etc attached - but then the main benefit is that you don't need to remove the whole system to enjoy a quiet journey. If you don't need the accessory then take it off, the bars can stay on and not irritate you like some of the square bars do.
Also, poke holes in dead tennis balls and jam them on the ends of your bars. It will keep your passengers from clonking themselves, not just because they are softer and rounder than factory caps, they are bright. It's easy to lose track of exactly where black-on-black bar ends are in space, even when you're looking for them; it's hard to overlook glowing lime-green spheres. You'll have to replace them each year as they fade; remove the factory caps beforehand so you won't pull them off inside the tennis balls.
I don’t get this comment. With the square bars you just clamp anything straight on. With the slots you have to faff about with the plastic strip in the slot don’t you (ie. cutting it to the right size, slotting bits of it in and out in the right combination for whatever you’re putting on). Or do people not use the strip. I’m not trying to be augmentative BTW, genuinely interested I currently have square bars but am considering aero/wing bars for an imminent car change.
The hull a port I like it because it fits almost every rack. And like most of the reviews wonder why it has plastic mountings. Well, figured that out one day when driving under a garage where the door was a little low. The clamps under the hull a port broke. But then don't think they were designed to drive into a roof. Have tightened those hex bolts pretty tight, so the plastic bends but doesn't break under designed usage. But the hullaports do shimmy and shake when there isn't a boat attached. The angle of the j-shape fits one of my boats perfectly (Chilco) but on my Quest it isn't deep enough, I would like a better fit.
To aid you with your rack selection process, The Rack Warehouse lists the most popular selling Thule 460R Rapid Podium Foot Complete Car Roof Rack fits alphabetically by Auto Manufacturer. You'll find perfect fitting roof racks for most of today's top selling vehicles on this list. Thule 460R Rapid Podium Foot Complete Car Roof Racks are designed for vehicles with factory fixed points, rail tracks and bolt through applications. If you don't see your vehicle on this list, simply click on the Thule Fit Guide at the top of the page, enter your vehicle information and the Thule Fit Guide will do the rest.
A great way to take your hobby to the next level, however, is to get your car involved. Whilst that may sound a little strange, cars and bikes can have a positive partnership than many people assume – we’re thinking more PB & J rather than Tom and Jerry here. A car opens up the horizons for your bike-riding hobby, allowing you to ride in new, fun locations.
When you want to travel fully equipped and leave nothing behind, Thule Motion XT is the perfect companion. This family-sized roof box will safely carry all of your luggage, outdoor gear and bulky loads wherever your travels lead. The range of user-friendly features include quick and secure mounting on the car, smooth opening and closing of the lid, and DualSide opening for easy access.
Part conservationists, part outdoorsman, part storyteller, Matt has devoted much of his life to environmentalism and that crafty, fleeting mistress known as writing. Having worked with over two-dozen brands and lifestyle publications, he’s carried out his passion for all things flora, fauna, and fiction through a litany of written mediums — one adventure, one sentence at a time.
This is a well-made bike rack with an unusual-looking design. The design works better than the FreeRide and ProRide models when it comes to loading on your bike. It also offers better inbuilt security for your bike and furthermore does not touch the frame and so cannot damage the frame. It’s quite a bit more expensive than the FreeRide model and a little bit heavier BUT it is selling at about the same price as the ProRide…it IS better than the ProRide; I guess people don’t buy it because of the looks and the weight.
I bought these Aero bars for my 2016 Jeep Wrangler Unlimited. Also purchased the Thule 300R gutter low feet. Make sure you link out to the Thule site to determine the right combinations of feet/bars to fit your vehicle when placing your order. The bars are good quality but installation instructions are a joke. They reference the foot pack for installation instructions. The foot pack tells you nothing beyond a vague illustration on how to install. Here is what I found out after several attempts and gouging out flesh on my left thumb:
No caps included. Really!?! Is this too much to ask? It is hard to believe that ordering Roof racks has so much deception involved. Yakima won't give parts numbers unless you go to a dealer, Thule leaves out pictured parts. Now I have to chase these caps down before installation. What else don't I know about this deal? Make sure you understand what I am saying: If ordering is not clear, it is NOT A QUALITY item. Go to a product that promotes honesty. I am open to suggestions. Right now I am considering sending the whole deal back.
Long road trips and overlanding adventures are only done right when you pack until your vehicle is almost overflowing. But if you’re playing Tetris with bags and your truck is bursting at the welds, chances are you won’t be able to see anything out the rear window — and that’s not safe. Roof racks are great for spreading gear to the often unused and underutilized space on the roof, but also for storing gear that won’t fit in your car to begin with. Paddleboards, mountain bikes and kayaks should all ride topside, especially after a long weekend of hard use.
These are ideal if you are carrying kayaks or bikes and know that lifting these into the centre of the roof will put a strain on your back. They're almost essential for safe loading on tall and / or wide vehicles. The bars slide out so you can load, for example, two bikes on the left side of your vehicle, then slide them the other way and load two more on the right. They're brilliant.